Lutra/docs/target-app-parity.md
danny 851d438e2a
Some checks are pending
ci / ci (macos-15) (push) Waiting to run
ci / ci (ubuntu-24.04) (push) Waiting to run
ci / ci (windows-2025) (push) Waiting to run
PM: review cycle 1
Stage line, feature breadth estimate, M1-M3 hours recalibrated x0.1
after cycle C1 (2.5 h agent time for 37 h estimated).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-15 18:38:39 +02:00

9 KiB
Raw Blame History

Target-app parity

Status: M1 in progress (text buffer, VFS, engine workspace, project tree, tabs and a plain-text editor in the app), no PHP feature ships · Last updated: 2026-10-15 · Target: PhpStorm 2026.x

How this is measured

Each feature area gets a weight (how much a typical PHP developer uses it) and a score (how much of the documented behaviour Lutra has, judged by behaviour, not by menu items). The headline depth is the weighted sum. Every score is marked measured or estimated and must point to evidence (tests, commands, screenshots of Lutra). Behaviour references come from public PhpStorm documentation only, noted with URLs in plan/phpstorm/.

Hours are the estimated agent wall-clock hours for one agent to reach behaviour parity in the area, from zero. They are first estimates made at the end of M0 and are recalibrated after each milestone from merged-commit timestamps.

Feature areas

Area Weight Score Missing Hours (one agent) Evidence
Editor core 12 8% (est.) crash-recovery journal, syntax highlighting (M2), code folding, soft wrap and other editor settings, preview tab, pinned/split/reordered tabs, close others/all, reopen closed tab, tab limit, conflict UI for files changed on disk, autosave, encodings other than UTF-8, large-file mode, column selection and multi-caret checked against the docs ~110 (est.) M1.6: tabs and a CodeMirror 6 editor in the app (ui/src/components/editor/, ui/src/stores/editor.ts): open from the project tree or engine events, activate, close by button, middle click or Mod+W, dirty dot, Save / Don't Save / Cancel on closing a dirty tab, Mod+S / Mod+Alt+S from engine command specs, non-blocking notice for a dirty file changed or deleted on disk; local edits go to buffer.edit with version-based resync, CRLF files keep \r\n; undo/redo, multiple selections, search and bracket matching from CodeMirror's basic setup. Vitest: a burst of 400 keystrokes with stale versions and remote edits loses none, a CRLF burst with deletions converges, store and component tests against a fake engine (ui/tests/editor/, 22 tests). Checked in the app on Windows 11 with --control and ui.screenshot: typing via the UI and via buffer.edit, save to disk, close question, middle click, disk-change notice. 1 MB file (16,385 lines): engine file.open 80 ms over the control channel (debug build, measured), editor state 1–6 ms and first rendered view 4–11 ms in Chromium (measured), ≈ 90 ms in total (estimated, budget 150 ms). Graded against plan/phpstorm/03-editor-tabs.md. crates/text: rope buffer, positions, edits (M1.1, unit tests + proptests). M1.3: engine buffers with versions and dirty state, file.open, buffer.get, buffer.edit (UTF-16 change sets, stale_version), file.save, file.saveAll, buffer.close with unsaved-changes guard, line ending and BOM kept on save, clean buffers reload on external change; 14 integration tests on temp dirs (crates/engine/tests/workspace.rs)
Project view, VFS 6 8% (est.) views list (project / scopes), toolbar (Select Opened File, Expand/Collapse All), sort and display options, show/hide excluded, distinct icons for library and excluded folders, file colours, speed search, preview, file operations, showing truncated listings ~37 (est.) lutra-vfs (M1.2): lazy sorted listing, ignore rules (.gitignore, .ignore, info/exclude, global excludes, Lutra defaults), native file watching via notify with a polling fallback, capped UTF-8 reads, atomic writes; 34 tests on temp dirs, watcher tests run on both backends (crates/vfs/tests). M1.5: project tree UI (lazy listing, keyboard navigation, dimmed ignored entries, event refresh) in ui/src/components/project/, Vitest against a mocked engine. M1.3: project.open, project.close, project.children (watches listed directories, capped at 256 native / 32 polling, least recently listed dropped), treeChanged events from disk, events.subscribe on the control channel with a TCP test (crates/control/tests/events.rs). M1.4: the tree runs against the engine in the app: folder picker (project.openDialog) and lutra-desktop --control PORT PATH open a project, the tree lists it lazily with ignored (var/ from .gitignore) and excluded (node_modules) entries dimmed, a file created on disk appears in an expanded folder within ~100 ms; verified with ui.screenshot on Windows 11 and Vitest (ui/tests/project/, ui/tests/ipcEvents.test.ts). Graded against plan/phpstorm/02-project-view.md: tool window, folder-first tree, dimmed ignored/excluded, keyboard navigation and live refresh exist; most toolbar, view and display options do not
Navigation 10 0% everything ~120 (est.) —
Search and replace 6 0% everything ~80 (est.) —
Code completion 10 0% everything ~250 (est.) —
Inspections and quick-fixes 8 0% everything ~300 (est.) —
Refactoring 7 0% everything ~250 (est.) —
Code style and formatting 4 0% everything ~120 (est.) —
Git 8 0% everything ~150 (est.) —
Terminal 3 0% everything ~30 (est.) —
Run configurations 2 0% everything ~50 (est.) —
Debugger 5 0% everything ~120 (est.) —
Testing 4 0% everything ~80 (est.) —
Composer and interpreters 2 0% everything ~50 (est.) —
Frameworks 5 0% everything ~300 (est.) —
Database tools 3 0% everything ~250 (est.) —
HTTP client 1 0% everything ~60 (est.) —
Web languages 2 0% everything ~200 (est.) —
Docker and remote 1 0% everything ~120 (est.) —
Settings, keymaps, themes 1 0% settings UI, keymaps, theme switching (theme tokens exist in lutra_engine::theme) ~60 (est.) —
Plug-ins 0.5 0% everything ~120 (est.) —
AI features 0.5 0% everything ~60 (est.) —

Sum: about 2,920 h. Adding UI fidelity (~150 h), localization (~40 h), performance (~100 h) and stability hardening (~100 h) gives the ROADMAP's ~3,300 h to full parity. These are the raw first estimates. Cycle C1 (M1.1–M1.6) took 2.5 h of agent time for 37 h estimated (factor 0.07), so the calibrated full-parity figure is ~330 h if that speed holds for deeper areas; the ROADMAP shows the range 300–3,300 h until M2/M3 give data for language work. The range is wide (2,000–5,000 h): completion, inspections, refactoring and frameworks depend on an own type-inference engine whose size is hard to judge before M6.

Weights were reviewed at the end of M0 and kept: nothing built so far gives a reason to change them.

What ships (M0, 2026-10-14)

No PHP feature. The foundation, verified on Windows 11:

  • cargo xtask ci passes all 13 steps (fmt, clippy with no-panic lints, tests, lints self-test, layers, assets, clean-room, cargo-deny licences, pnpm install, ESLint, vue-tsc, Vitest, frontend licences).
  • Commands app.about and app.quit with unit tests; a panicking command is caught by the guard (crates/engine/src/engine.rs tests).
  • Control channel: app.ping, engine.execute, engine.listCommands, ui.screenshot, with proptests and a TCP integration test (crates/control), and checked against the running app.
  • The desktop window opens themed from Rust tokens and shows the product name and version that the frontend gets from app.about over IPC.

What ships (M1, in progress)

The project tree is the first user-visible feature (Project view 8%, estimated); every other score stays 0%.

  • M1.1 text buffer (crates/text): Buffer on a ropey rope with byte, char, UTF-16 and line counts; byte offset to line and column in UTF-16 code units or chars and back, all fallible (out of range, inside a character, inside a CRLF, inside a surrogate pair); atomic Edit batches in LSP TextEdit[] semantics that reject reversed, out-of-range and overlapping ranges; / / detection with a keep-the-file's-ending save policy. 23 unit tests and 6 proptests (round-trips on emoji, ZWJ sequences, CJK and combining marks; random edit batches checked against a String model, never panicking).

Revision history

Date Change Summary
2026-10-15 minor Calibration note after cycle C1 (factor 0.07)
2026-10-15 minor Editor core 0% → 8% (estimated): tabs and editor in the app (M1.6)
2026-10-15 minor Project view 0% → 8% (estimated): tree runs against the engine in the app (M1.4)
2026-10-14 minor Project view evidence: project tree UI (M1.5), score unchanged
2026-10-14 minor M1.3 engine workspace evidence (Editor core, Project view; scores unchanged)
2026-10-14 minor M1.1 text buffer evidence (Editor core, score unchanged)
2026-10-14 minor Project view evidence: native file watching (M1.2b), score unchanged
2026-10-14 minor Project view evidence: lutra-vfs (M1.2), score unchanged
2026-10-14 minor Hours per area, weights reviewed, M0 evidence
2026-10-13 major Baseline